AboutLocation(504) 349-6713

Dealing with the Crisis at OHA

by | Feb 15, 1999 | Articles | 15,911 comments

The Preamble

During the late 1980’s, the New Orleans Office of Hearings and Appeals had 12 Administrative Law Judges, each of whom had a caseload of 200-250 claimants. Through illness, death, and resignation the number of ALJ’s has shrunk to 7, and because of the huge nationwide increase in disability applications, the average caseload is now over 1,000 claimants per judge!! This convergence of a diminishing number of judges and rising number of claims literally brought the New Orleans OHA to a standstill during the latter half of 1993. When it because apparent that the only resolution of this national trend would be strong local action, a core group of attorneys and ALJ’s informally banded together in an effort to ease our client’s agony. It has always been difficult for our clients to wait 4-6 months from the reconsideration denial for their hearing. But when that delay routinely began stretching to 6-12 months, their cries of frustration could not be ignored by even the most hard-hearted.

Yes, Virginia, There Is A Crisis

Any lawyer with a decent caseload of disability clients knew that something went terribly wrong with the system last year. How could we have more cases than ever before at OHA but less hearings held, and less decisions rendered? Everyone likes to point fingers, but would you like the job of telling the ALJ’s to work harder?

The first crack in the dam of apathy came when the HOCALJ in New Orleans wrote a letter to the newspaper and attributed the delays to the increase in filings, but definitely not to the laziness of his “loyal and devoted” hearing assistants and hearing clerks. How a letter to the editor could relieve hunger and suffering was a mystery to other ALJ’s and lawyers alike. But it caused a reaction.

At the urging of several judges, I responded. (See Exhibit A). I requested a meeting of all interested ALJ’s and claimants’ representatives in an effort to see if a local solution could be hammered out. I was told by an ALJ that when my letter was presented to the other judges, the notion of a “crisis” was ridiculed, and the idea of meeting with those pesky lawyers was laughed at. One judge said his tennis game was more important, and one judge blamed “unprepared attorneys” for the entire crisis! I swear it.

Cooler heads must have prevailed because a few days later, a letter appeared on the Security Guard’s desk at OHA, announcing a meeting in 10 days. (See Exhibit B). Now, the pressure was on, because we actually had to figure out what to propose. But in the midst of a brutally cold winter, the blanket of poverty is very thin, and the sad voices of our clients showed the way.

The Meeting

Some of them were friendly, some were ciphers, and some wore a long face. But they were there. Each and every one of the 7 ALJ’s was waiting for us when we arrived at Federal Court for our meeting. It was probably the first time in the history of Louisiana that all of the judges in one discipline met with the lawyers who represent 75% of their cases.

The Chief Judge opened the meeting by asking me if I had any opening comments. Nothing like being put on the spot! But, I was ready.

In an effort to ameliorate the crisis, I made four proposals:

  • Within 60 days, all attorneys with “aged” cases not yet set for hearing, should be permitted to come to OHA for a “Scheduling Day”. The attorneys would meet with the hearing assistant for each ALJ, and seek to get cases scheduled where more than 12 months had elapsed since the Request for Hearing had been filed.
  • To assuage angry ALJ’s and hearing assistants, who claim that New Orleans lawyers are sending in numerous duplicate medical records (and thereby wasting “hours” of their precious time culling the duplicates) all attorneys will assume responsibility for the problem. Should any attorney send in duplicates that will lead to more than 10 minutes of culling, the hearing assistant will call the attorney’s office immediately, and a staff member will be sent to OHA to eliminate the problem. (No calls yet!).
  • The central mail system at OHA is an abomination. Important medical evidence can be hand-delivered to the OHA mail clerks before a hearing, and it disappears into a Black Hole! Where does it go? Accordingly, I proposed that all lawyers be permitted to personally place any mail for an ALJ, directly into that ALJ’s mail slot. That way, we know it will get to the ALJ or else we know who is responsible for the vanishing act.
  • A committee of ALJ’s and lawyers should be set up to initiate, analyze, and implement any reasonable proposals which would lead to a better working relationship between judges and attorneys. I suggested that there be four ALJ’s and three lawyers on the committee, and that the committee meet periodically. All members of the committee must be completely rotated every six months.

Other attorneys in attendance also had suggestions, such as scheduling hearings far enough in advance so that updated medicals could be obtained prior to the hearing. After two and one half hours of discussion, the HOCALJ decided that I would meet with him to discuss putting some of these ideas into effect. We left believing that changes would be made, and, to a very limited extent, we have been proven partially correct.

The Implementation

Within a week of the en banc meeting, I met with the HOCALJ. A proposal for a new incoming mail system and central file system was circulated by an interested ALJ prior to the meeting, but was tabled. (See exhibit C). No steps were taken to form an ongoing committee of ALJ’s and attorneys either. What was acted upon was the request to have a Scheduling Day.

In my discussion with the HOCALJ and his staff, we learned that OHA can print out, in five minutes, a list of cases at OHA, by attorney, and in chronological order by request for hearing date. (See exhibit D, which represents one page of the March printout). This meant that OHA could now identify every lawyer’s oldest cases and we could seek to get those scheduled as soon as possible. To facilitate scheduling, OHA announced a Scheduling Day every second Wednesday of the month. The chronological printout was to be made available to the attorney on the Friday before Scheduling Day, so the lawyer could prepare for scheduling. (See Notice to Attorneys, exhibit E). In return for this scheduling project, the attorneys agreed to dispense with the issuance of a Notice of Hearing. One ALJ had each attorney sign the Oral Confirmation of Hearing. (See exhibit F).

Chipping Away At the Backlog

We have had two Scheduling Days since the meeting of lawyers and ALJ’s. I scheduled forty of my most aged cases on those two days, simply by meeting with each ALJ’s hearing assistant. In between Scheduling Days, the OHA staff continues to call and schedule those cases that the ALJ wants to set for a hearing. While this by no means represents a substantial number of cases scheduled, it does represent a significant number of aged cases scheduled. The only cases waiting for scheduling now which are over a year old are those that are lost, or which were lost and recently located. March, 1994 was our busiest month of all time in terms of hearings held.

We are in business to move cases along, and at long last, there is some brief glimmer of hope that the log jam will be set free.

Other Methods of Expediting Cases

Over the last few months, the attorneys and judges have managed to hammer out two other means of speeding up the dreadfully slow process. “On the record” favorable decisions are now being rendered at a greater rate. However, many of the judges are looking for compromises, and we are being asked to consent to amended onset dates and closed periods. Of course, it is imperative that you obtain your client’s permission prior to consenting to the compromise.

Several ALJ’s have allowed the attorneys to draft favorable decisions. We are in favor of this procedure, because we can get the decision out in one day, rather than waiting 90-120 days — the usual delay after the hearing at our OHA. Taking the time to write the decision is no harder than drafting proposed findings of fact and conclusions of law in a federal litigation case. To help out, the ALJ’s have informally approved a boilerplate Favorable Decision which I have annexed. (See exhibit G).

Some Closing Thoughts

Sometimes I worry that having so many hearings in a short time is like being a practitioner in Traffic Court. Are we trying to move too many cases through an antiquated system?

I really don’t think so. The Social Security Administration has kept these people waiting so overly long that any meaningful steps we take on their behalf are far better than having their case remain in legal limbo. We have not accomplished much yet. So far, we are merely getting more cases heard. But, it is a start, and at least we have established a meaningful dialogue with ALJ’s who had at first refused to meet with us. I do not believe that you can gain the reputation you desire if you allow OHA to remain paralyzed.

Get the cases moving! Call your HOCALJ today!!

15,911 Comments

  1. Antoniolic on December 20, 2021 at 9:33 pm

    Absolutely with you it agree. It is good idea. I support you.
    YES, this intelligible message
    To fill a blank?
    Has casually found today this forum and it was specially registered to participate in discussion.
    I think, that you are not right. Let’s discuss.

    http://jfmusiconline.com/shell/

  2. Antoniolic on December 29, 2021 at 9:48 am

    The Associate Fellow membership category provides an opportunity for surgeons who are beginning surgical practice and who meet specific requirements to assume an active role in the College at an early stage in their careers.

  3. Antoniolic on December 30, 2021 at 8:09 pm

    The areas of special interest and expertise are self-reported. Initiates are surgeons who have completed the application process to become a Fellow of the American College of Surgeons and are awaiting formal induction at the Clinical Congress. The Associate Fellow membership category provides an opportunity for surgeons who are beginning surgical practice and who meet specific requirements to assume an active role in the College at an early stage in their careers.

  6. link on February 16, 2022 at 3:14 pm

    Дивитися фільми українською
    мовою онлайн в HD якості link

  8. Папы 2022 on February 21, 2022 at 4:38 pm

    Не пропустіть кращі новинки кіно українською 2021 року Папы 2022

  9. Link on February 21, 2022 at 7:45 pm

    Всі фільми новинки 2020 року
    онлайн українською в хорошій якості Link

  10. Папы 2022 on February 22, 2022 at 8:48 am

    Нові сучасні фільми дивитися
    українською мовою онлайн в хорошій якості HD
    Папы 2022

  14. Link on February 23, 2022 at 7:03 pm

    Фільми та серiали 2020 українською мовою в
    HD якості Link

  15. Link on February 23, 2022 at 8:52 pm

    Фільми та серiали 2020 українською мовою в HD якості Link

  16. Link on February 23, 2022 at 11:11 pm

    Не пропустіть кращі новинки кіно українською
    2021 року Link

  17. Link on February 24, 2022 at 1:02 am

    Новинки фільми, серіали, мультфільми 2021 року, які вже вийшли Ви можете дивитися українською на
    нашому сайті Link

  18. Link on February 24, 2022 at 3:08 am

    Нові фільми 2021 року. Link

  21. filmiwap.store on February 27, 2022 at 5:47 am

    Фільми українською в хорошій якості – онлайн без реклами filmiwap.store

  23. link on February 28, 2022 at 4:47 pm

    Нові фільми 2021 року. link

  24. link on March 15, 2022 at 10:45 pm

    Найкращі фільми 2021 link

  25. Thomanidiamb on March 18, 2022 at 5:35 pm

    Sеlf-Imрrovеment аnd succеss go hand in hand. Taking thе steрs tо mаkе yourself a bеtter аnd mоre wеll-rounded individuаl will prоvе to bе a wisе dеcisiоn. https://thoughtoftheday.btcfreedom.design
    Thе wisе рersоn fеels thе pain оf onе аrrоw. The unwise fееls thе раin оf two.
    Whеn lооking fоr wise wоrds, the best ones оften come from оur еldеrs.
    You’vе heard that it’s wisе tо learn frоm еxрeriencе, but it is wiser tо lеаrn frоm the experiеncе оf оthеrs.
    Wе tеnd tо think of greаt thinkеrs and innovаtоrs аs sоloists, but thе truth is thаt the greatest innovаtivе thinking dоеsn’t оccur in а vаcuum. Innоvation rеsults frоm collaboration.
    Sоme оf us think holding on makes us strоng, but sоmetimеs it is letting go.
    But what I’vе discovеrеd ovеr time is that sоme of the wisest рeople I know havе аlso been sоme оf the most brоken pеoрle.
    Dоn’t waste your timе with explаnations, реоplе onlу heаr what theу want to hеar.
    Tо makе difficult dеcisiоns wisеly, it helps tо havе a systеmаtic рrоcess for аssessing eаch choice аnd its cоnsequencеs – the pоtential impact on eаch аsрect of yоur life.
    Each оf us еxpеriencеs dеfeats in life. Wе cаn trаnsform dеfеаt intо victorу if we lеаrn frоm life’s whuррings.

  26. Frenchmxjf on March 23, 2022 at 4:57 pm

    Don’t waste yоur timе with еxplanаtiоns, peоple only heаr whаt thеy want tо hеar.

  91. link on April 29, 2022 at 12:18 pm

    BC

  104. Link on May 8, 2022 at 4:55 am

    Нові сучасні фільми дивитися українською мовою онлайн в хорошій якості HD Link

  107. Link on May 9, 2022 at 2:38 am

    Нові фільми 2021 року. Link

  108. Link on May 9, 2022 at 3:33 am

    Дивитися популярні фільми 2021-2021 року
    Link

  109. Link on May 9, 2022 at 4:07 am

    Найкращі українські фільми 2021 року Link

  110. Link on May 9, 2022 at 4:16 am

    Дивитися популярні фільми 2021-2021 року Link

  111. Link on May 9, 2022 at 4:24 am

    Найкращі фільми 2021 Link

  112. Link on May 9, 2022 at 4:33 am

    Дивитися фільми українською мовою онлайн в HD якості Link

  114. Link on May 9, 2022 at 5:26 am

    Дивитися фільми онлайн в HD якості
    українською мовою Link

  116. 2022 on May 9, 2022 at 11:25 am

    Новинки фільми, серіали, мультфільми 2021 року, які вже вийшли Ви можете
    дивитися українською на нашому сайті 2022

  141. Tomasz Michałowski on May 20, 2022 at 10:17 pm

    There is apparently a bundle to identify about this. I suppose you made certain nice points in features also.

  145. Link on May 22, 2022 at 11:12 pm

    Всі фільми новинки 2020 року онлайн українською в хорошій якості Link

  155. Link on May 27, 2022 at 9:07 am

    Дивитися фільми українською онлайн Link

  158. Link on May 27, 2022 at 5:24 pm

    Всі фільми новинки 2020 року онлайн
    українською в хорошій якості
    Link

  202. об онлайн on May 29, 2022 at 8:36 pm

    Смотреть аниме онлайн в любимой озучке..
    Тутоб онлайн.

    Лучшие фильмы в жанре боевик на ГидОнлайн.

  516. canadian pharmacies online on June 16, 2022 at 4:33 am

    Article writing is also a fun, if you be acquainted
    with after that you can write or else it is complex
    to write.